Water stargrass: Difference between revisions

From Yakipedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 13: Line 13:
* Reduced recreation opportunities and challenges to boating and fishing
* Reduced recreation opportunities and challenges to boating and fishing


== Studies ==
== Stargrass Research and Monitoring ==
Multiple studies have been completed or are on-going on stargrass and the Lower Yakima River.  
Multiple studies focused on water stargrass and its impacts on the Yakima River have been completed or are on-going, and new monitoring and research work is being developed to ensure that expanding treatment efforts are effective. Completed studies include:


A 2009 report<ref>Wise, D. R., M. Zuroske, K. D. Carpenter, and R. L. Kiesling. 2009. Assessment of Eutrophication in the Lower Yakima River Basin, Washington 2004-07. Page 108. U.S. Geological Survey, Investigations Report 2009–5078.</ref> by the USGS and Benton Conservation District detailed a 2004-2007 assessment of eutrophication in the lower 116 miles of the Yakima River. This was one of the first studies that characterized the proliferation of water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. [https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2009/5078/pdf/sir20095078.pdf See PDF]
* A 2009 report<ref>Wise, D. R., M. Zuroske, K. D. Carpenter, and R. L. Kiesling. 2009. Assessment of Eutrophication in the Lower Yakima River Basin, Washington 2004-07. Page 108. U.S. Geological Survey, Investigations Report 2009–5078.</ref> by the USGS and Benton Conservation District detailed a 2004-2007 assessment of eutrophication in the lower 116 miles of the Yakima River. This was one of the first studies that characterized the proliferation of water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. [https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2009/5078/pdf/sir20095078.pdf See PDF]
* The [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Lower_Yakima_Assessment.pdf 2011 Lower Yakima River Assessment] completed by the Benton Conservation District includes a chapter on water stargrass and the issues it causes<ref>Appel, M., R. Little, H. Wendt, and M. Nielson. 2011. Assessment of the Lower Yakima River in Benton County, Washington. Page 182. Benton Conservation District.</ref>. [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Lower_Yakima_Assessment.pdf See PDF]
* Aaron Pelly's 2020 Master's Thesis focuses on water stargrass and its impacts on water quality in the Lower Yakima River<ref>Pelly, A. C. 2020. Overabundant macrophyte growth alters ecosystem function in a lowland river. Washington State University.</ref>. [https://doi.org/10.7273/000004124 See PDF]
* The USGS and Benton Conservation District released a 2025 draft report on stargrass and water quality in the Lower Yakima River from 2018-2020 [https://doi.org/10.31223/X5JT8P See PDF]. The data is available on the USGS website, [https://data.usgs.gov/datacatalog/data/USGS:62d987d3d34e2842e1edcfcd link].


A 2011 assessment of the Lower Yakima River includes a chapter on water stargrass<ref>Appel, M., R. Little, H. Wendt, and M. Nielson. 2011. Assessment of the Lower Yakima River in Benton County, Washington. Page 182. Benton Conservation District.</ref>. [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Lower_Yakima_Assessment.pdf See PDF]
Ongoing monitoring efforts include: '''REVIEW TEAM- help us update!'''


A 2020 Master's Thesis on water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River<ref>Pelly, A. C. 2020. Overabundant macrophyte growth alters ecosystem function in a lowland river. Washington State University.</ref>. [https://doi.org/10.7273/000004124 See PDF]
establishment of USGS WAter quality gages


The USGS and Benton Conservation District released a 2025 draft report on stargrass and water quality in the Lower Yakima River from 2018-2020 [https://doi.org/10.31223/X5JT8P See PDF]. The data is available on the USGS website, [https://data.usgs.gov/datacatalog/data/USGS:62d987d3d34e2842e1edcfcd link].
BIOMASS SURVEYS
 
DRONE SURVEYS


== Stargrass Control Efforts ==
== Stargrass Control Efforts ==


In the last few years Benton County Conservation District has ramped up efforts to control water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass are discussed in this report by the Benton Conservation District<ref>Pelly, A., M. Appel, and R. Little. 2021. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Benton Conservation District.</ref> [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Water-Stargrass-Management-Techniques_2021-09-17.pdf Link]
Over the last decade, the Benton County Conservation District (BCD) has researched and piloted several techniques to control water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass are discussed in detail in this BCD report <ref>Pelly, A., M. Appel, and R. Little. 2021. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Benton Conservation District.</ref> [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Water-Stargrass-Management-Techniques_2021-09-17.pdf Link]  
 
In 2024, BCD an Mid-Columbia Fisheries completed a 


Starting in 2024, key partners came together to form the Water Stargrass Coalition and develop a shared strategy for addressing the negative impacts of water stargrass on the Lower Yakima. In the spring of 2025, the leadership group of the Yakima Basin Integrated Plan focused on highlighting the importance of reducing stargrass impacts and securing significant financial investments to accelerate work on the ground. As part of this effort, the Roza Irrigation District produced a good overview of stargrass control strategies and efforts in the Lower Yakima River, [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Revell_2025_WaterStargrassOverview.pdf see PDF]. The coalition is implementing several pilot projects in the summer/fall of 2025 and is working on developing a longer-term work plan to coordinate activities and secure support and funding for expanding control work and associated monitoring and research in the future.  
Starting in 2024, key partners came together to form the Water Stargrass Coalition and develop a shared strategy for addressing the negative impacts of water stargrass on the Lower Yakima. In the spring of 2025, the leadership group of the Yakima Basin Integrated Plan focused on highlighting the importance of reducing stargrass impacts and securing significant financial investments to accelerate work on the ground. As part of this effort, the Roza Irrigation District produced a good overview of stargrass control strategies and efforts in the Lower Yakima River, [https://ybfwrb.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Revell_2025_WaterStargrassOverview.pdf see PDF]. The coalition is implementing several pilot projects in the summer/fall of 2025 and is working on developing a longer-term work plan to coordinate activities and secure support and funding for expanding control work and associated monitoring and research in the future.  
Line 32: Line 39:
'''Hand'''  
'''Hand'''  


The most effective approach to manage stargrass is to remove the plant material at the roots. The simplest and most straight forward method is hand pulling with or without tools. Several hand-pulling projects have been completed over the last decade, and have shown that treatments can improve water quality, reduce future stargrass growth, and restore conditions that support fall chinook spawning. but they effort would needed to be ramped up considerably to make an improvement.  
The most effective approach to manage stargrass is to remove the plant material at the roots. The simplest and most straight forward method is hand pulling with or without tools. Several hand-pulling projects have been completed over the last decade, and have shown that treatments can improve water quality, reduce future stargrass growth, and restore conditions that support fall chinook spawning. Hand-pulling is relatively slow and works best in shallower areas and lower flow velocities, limiting its broad application throughout the river; it can be effective in clearing smaller priority areas.  
 


'''Mechanical'''
'''Mechanical'''  
 
Mechanical harvesters cut the plant above the sediment and remove the cut plant material from the water. 
 
Mechanical harvesting began in 2021. With approximately 16 acres harvested in 2024. The focus of removal locations has been in the Yakima Delta area, the Wanawish Dam pool, and Prosser Dam pool. A mechanical harvester reaches to a depth of about 3 feet and harvest would need to occur multiple times during the summer. 
 


Mechanical harvesting typically uses a floating barge/boat equipped with either a cutter head (which typically mow the plan above the roots) or a roller (which can pull the plants, including roots, up, resulting in longer term control). Harvested plants may be removed from the water for onshore disposal or left in river to be washed downstream (allowing much more rapid operations). Mechanical harvesting began in 2021, when BCD acquired an [https://lakeweedharvester.com/eco-harvester/ Ecoharvester]. ,. The focus of removal locations has been in the Yakima Delta area, the Wanawish Dam pool, the Benton City area and Prosser Dam pool. Pilot work has help determine where the harvester can and cannot operate well, and has confirmed that when using the roller head, it can significantly reduce plant densities in a way that persists in subsequent years. Approximately 16 acres were harvested in 2024. Several additional harvesters of varying sizes have been ordered in 2025 and should be fully operational in 2026. Partners are also exploring the use of land-based and amphibious harvesting equipment, including a summer of 2025 pilot of a spyder excavator led by WDFW.


'''Herbicides'''  
'''Herbicides'''  


Potential aquatic herbicide treatments are being assessed. Potential herbicides being considered are only endothall, imazamox, carfentrazone-ethyl, and fluridone.  
Potential aquatic herbicide treatments are being assessed; herbicides being considered include endothall, imazamox, carfentrazone-ethyl, and fluridone. Local partners are working closely with US Army Corps of Engineers and Bureau of Reclamation aquatic plant management specialists who have experience with similar work in other area to evaluate whether and how herbicide treatments could be piloted in the Yakima River.
 
 


'''Flows Management'''
'''Flow Management'''


There is the potential that flow management strategies could help manage water stargrass. High flow events or managed pulse flows in the spring and early summer could reduce early water stargrass biomass growth. The mechanism is likely through bed scouring and erosion that help uproot the plant and reduce establishment and also reduces early plant growth. Although flow management has potential, a pilot study and monitoring would be an important step to better understand this control method.
Flow conditions have a major impact on stargrass growth. In years where high, cool and turbid flows last through late spring, stargrass growth is significantly reduced; in low flow years it starts much earlier and grows much faster. This is due to a combination of reduced light availability for growing plants and cooler temperatures slowing growth. Higher flows- typical of winter and spring floods, break off stargrass and may even remove entire plants, including the roots when velocities are high enough to scour the bed, reducing the extent of stargrass in the next growing season. There is also anecdotal evidence that late spring/summer pulse flows released by the Bureau of Reclamation to encourage sockeye and summer chinook migration dislodge and move significant amounts of stargrass downstream; while this can create short-term problems at fish ladders and irrigation diversions, it has also been reported to have reduced stargrass issues at these sites for weeks after. The Water Stargrass Coalition is working to identify flow and turbidity management strategies that can help reduce the impacts of stragrass on the river while also meeting other fish and water supply objectives.  


== Websites ==
== Digital Resources ==
Benton Conservation District - Water Stargrass Management. [https://www.bentoncd.org/water-stargrass-removal Link] [https://www.bentoncd.org/saving-our-river Videos]
Benton Conservation District - [https://www.bentoncd.org/water-stargrass-removal Water Stargrass Management Page]. [https://www.bentoncd.org/saving-our-river BCD Water Stagrass Videos]


Mid-Columbia Fisheries Enhancement Group - Water Stargrass. [https://www.midcolumbiafisheries.org/yakima-river-vegetation-assessments Link]
Mid-Columbia Fisheries Enhancement Group - [https://www.midcolumbiafisheries.org/yakima-river-vegetation-assessments Water Stargrass Page]


State of Washington Water Research Center Spring 2025 Seminar Series- Water Stargrass Video [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEiqE0_KHkI YouTube Link]
State of Washington Water Research Center [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEiqE0_KHkI Spring 2025 Seminar Series- Water Stargrass Video]  


== Media Coverage ==
== Media Coverage ==

Revision as of 14:42, 5 September 2025

Overview and Concerns

Water stargrass (Heteranthera dubia) is a species of perennial aquatic plant in the Pontederiaceae family. It lives in freshwater such as lakes, rivers, and irrigation canals; preferring calmer waters. In the Lower Yakima River, water stargrass is prolific in many stretches of the lower 47 miles, below Prosser Diversion Dam. Water stargrass forms a bank to bank monoculture and can grow from stream bottom to the water surface and then continue growing horizontally forming a canopy at the water surface. It also forms dense vegetative mats over stream substrates covering gravels cobbles.

Water stargrass causes a suite of issues including:

  • River displacement from total volume of water stargrass
  • Increased sedimentation from reduced streamflow
  • Changes to bottom substrates and gravel quality that reduce salmonid spawning habitat
  • Changes to fish migration
  • Changes in water quality including fluctuations in dissolved oxygen levels and pH from stargrass respiration and photosynthesis
  • Plugged or or block irrigation screens and fish ladders
  • Reduced recreation opportunities and challenges to boating and fishing

Stargrass Research and Monitoring

Multiple studies focused on water stargrass and its impacts on the Yakima River have been completed or are on-going, and new monitoring and research work is being developed to ensure that expanding treatment efforts are effective. Completed studies include:

  • A 2009 report[1] by the USGS and Benton Conservation District detailed a 2004-2007 assessment of eutrophication in the lower 116 miles of the Yakima River. This was one of the first studies that characterized the proliferation of water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. See PDF
  • The 2011 Lower Yakima River Assessment completed by the Benton Conservation District includes a chapter on water stargrass and the issues it causes[2]. See PDF
  • Aaron Pelly's 2020 Master's Thesis focuses on water stargrass and its impacts on water quality in the Lower Yakima River[3]. See PDF
  • The USGS and Benton Conservation District released a 2025 draft report on stargrass and water quality in the Lower Yakima River from 2018-2020 See PDF. The data is available on the USGS website, link.

Ongoing monitoring efforts include: REVIEW TEAM- help us update!

establishment of USGS WAter quality gages

BIOMASS SURVEYS

DRONE SURVEYS

Stargrass Control Efforts

Over the last decade, the Benton County Conservation District (BCD) has researched and piloted several techniques to control water stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass are discussed in detail in this BCD report [4] Link

In 2024, BCD an Mid-Columbia Fisheries completed a

Starting in 2024, key partners came together to form the Water Stargrass Coalition and develop a shared strategy for addressing the negative impacts of water stargrass on the Lower Yakima. In the spring of 2025, the leadership group of the Yakima Basin Integrated Plan focused on highlighting the importance of reducing stargrass impacts and securing significant financial investments to accelerate work on the ground. As part of this effort, the Roza Irrigation District produced a good overview of stargrass control strategies and efforts in the Lower Yakima River, see PDF. The coalition is implementing several pilot projects in the summer/fall of 2025 and is working on developing a longer-term work plan to coordinate activities and secure support and funding for expanding control work and associated monitoring and research in the future.

Hand

The most effective approach to manage stargrass is to remove the plant material at the roots. The simplest and most straight forward method is hand pulling with or without tools. Several hand-pulling projects have been completed over the last decade, and have shown that treatments can improve water quality, reduce future stargrass growth, and restore conditions that support fall chinook spawning. Hand-pulling is relatively slow and works best in shallower areas and lower flow velocities, limiting its broad application throughout the river; it can be effective in clearing smaller priority areas.

Mechanical

Mechanical harvesting typically uses a floating barge/boat equipped with either a cutter head (which typically mow the plan above the roots) or a roller (which can pull the plants, including roots, up, resulting in longer term control). Harvested plants may be removed from the water for onshore disposal or left in river to be washed downstream (allowing much more rapid operations). Mechanical harvesting began in 2021, when BCD acquired an Ecoharvester. ,. The focus of removal locations has been in the Yakima Delta area, the Wanawish Dam pool, the Benton City area and Prosser Dam pool. Pilot work has help determine where the harvester can and cannot operate well, and has confirmed that when using the roller head, it can significantly reduce plant densities in a way that persists in subsequent years. Approximately 16 acres were harvested in 2024. Several additional harvesters of varying sizes have been ordered in 2025 and should be fully operational in 2026. Partners are also exploring the use of land-based and amphibious harvesting equipment, including a summer of 2025 pilot of a spyder excavator led by WDFW.

Herbicides

Potential aquatic herbicide treatments are being assessed; herbicides being considered include endothall, imazamox, carfentrazone-ethyl, and fluridone. Local partners are working closely with US Army Corps of Engineers and Bureau of Reclamation aquatic plant management specialists who have experience with similar work in other area to evaluate whether and how herbicide treatments could be piloted in the Yakima River.

Flow Management

Flow conditions have a major impact on stargrass growth. In years where high, cool and turbid flows last through late spring, stargrass growth is significantly reduced; in low flow years it starts much earlier and grows much faster. This is due to a combination of reduced light availability for growing plants and cooler temperatures slowing growth. Higher flows- typical of winter and spring floods, break off stargrass and may even remove entire plants, including the roots when velocities are high enough to scour the bed, reducing the extent of stargrass in the next growing season. There is also anecdotal evidence that late spring/summer pulse flows released by the Bureau of Reclamation to encourage sockeye and summer chinook migration dislodge and move significant amounts of stargrass downstream; while this can create short-term problems at fish ladders and irrigation diversions, it has also been reported to have reduced stargrass issues at these sites for weeks after. The Water Stargrass Coalition is working to identify flow and turbidity management strategies that can help reduce the impacts of stragrass on the river while also meeting other fish and water supply objectives.

Digital Resources

Benton Conservation District - Water Stargrass Management Page. BCD Water Stagrass Videos

Mid-Columbia Fisheries Enhancement Group - Water Stargrass Page

State of Washington Water Research Center Spring 2025 Seminar Series- Water Stargrass Video

Media Coverage

Type Source Title Date Notes
News KIMA News WDFW project targets invasive aquatic plant to improve habitat in Yakima River September 4, 2025
Blog WDFW Collaboration in the Yakima Basin: Project kicking off in September will remove water stargrass, improve habitat in Yakima River August 28, 2025

Citations

  1. Wise, D. R., M. Zuroske, K. D. Carpenter, and R. L. Kiesling. 2009. Assessment of Eutrophication in the Lower Yakima River Basin, Washington 2004-07. Page 108. U.S. Geological Survey, Investigations Report 2009–5078.
  2. Appel, M., R. Little, H. Wendt, and M. Nielson. 2011. Assessment of the Lower Yakima River in Benton County, Washington. Page 182. Benton Conservation District.
  3. Pelly, A. C. 2020. Overabundant macrophyte growth alters ecosystem function in a lowland river. Washington State University.
  4. Pelly, A., M. Appel, and R. Little. 2021. Management and Control Techniques for Water Stargrass in the Lower Yakima River. Benton Conservation District.